Saturday, October 15, 2016

How Addie's chapter changes the narrative

In any form of entertainment, there are people who stand out with their ability to stay relevant even through the dynamic interests of their audience. Ryan Higa, a popular YouTuber, has been creating videos for over 10 years now, but still has millions of views on his most recent videos. Addie seems to have achieved a similar feat in As I Lay Dying. Despite the fact that she dies relatively early after the beginning of the novel, she narrates her own chapter once the trip to Jackson is well under way. So how, or why, is Addie’s point of view still pertinent when she’s dead?

There is obviously a reason why Faulkner included multiple narrative points of view – if they contributed nothing to the story, it would only be useless and confusing to have them. The purposes, as I see them, are to give us various points of view on the same person (as we saw through the class activity about Anse) as well as a sense of each character’s unique qualities based on how they narrate (e.g. we learn that Cash is diligent but not all-too-interested in narrating to us, and that Vardaman is truly trying to make sense of what’s going on with Addie’s death and all). Readers can expect, then, that reading a chapter narrated by Addie herself will give us some insight into her feelings about her own life and death, about the journey to Jackson with her body, about the other characters, etc.

What we see in Addie’s chapter reflects these things and more. She starts off by telling readers “In the afternoon when school was out and the last one had left with his little dirty snuffling nose, instead of going home I would go down the hill to the spring where I could be quiet and hate them” (169). Well… Addie is not the most sympathetic person, it seems. This apathetic and somewhat contemptuous attitude continues throughout the chapter. Near the end, Addie says, “And now he has three children that are his and not mine. And then I could get ready to die” (176). This sentiment reflects a notion Addie learned from her father, that “the reason for living was to get ready to stay dead a long time” (169). Addie apparently thinks herself ready to die after having corrected the situation with her illegitimate child. Around the middle of the chapter, Addie discusses the word “love” and how she doesn’t see a place for it, but doesn’t really care if Anse uses it. Also, Addie says that she’ll get Anse to take her to Jackson when she’s dead as a form of revenge.

By making Addie seem wholly unconcerned about her life once all her mistakes had been corrected, I think Faulkner is trying to make the reader less likely to pity Addie during the journey to Jackson. If Addie had portrayed herself as someone who loved life, loved those close to her, and whose only dying wish was to be buried in Jackson, As I Lay Dying would have been a very different story. Addie’s corpse is terribly abused in the course of the journey, and if Addie had cared about her memory being honored, then the journey would be an abysmal failure and really quite hard to stomach. However, since Addie seems not to have cared too much about anything, we as readers can see the journey less like something which was truly important to Addie and more like something which she requested just for the hell of it; rather than feeling bad that Addie’s corpse is constantly being treated irreverently, we can focus on the journey itself and the characters who are still alive.

8 comments:

  1. I think you're right that the way Faulkner depicted Addie means that we don't feel much sympathy for her, and for me it goes even beyond that. Given that Addie is such an unlikable character, and that the only reason she wanted them to bury her in Jefferson was to get revenge, I am much more sympathetic to the rest of the Bundren family, who went through a major ordeal to fulfill what Anse thought was a serious dying wish.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't know if we can say "Addie didn't care too much about anything". Too be sure, she was a terrible wife, mother and schoolteacher, but I don't totally get a feeling of apathy from her chapter. She truly loves Jewel, to the point of worshipping him according to Cora. When her first child Cash is born, she says "I knew that living was terrible and that this was the answer to it", which I interpreted to mean that although she didn't love Cash, she did love her children. She just didn't like the word "motherhood" because she thought a word couldn't really reflect a real concept. Just my two cents.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yeeaaahhh, the novel would've been a very different kind of story if Addie were at all the nurturing mother figure she was built up to be in the chapters preceding hers. There would be some sense of righteousness or something about the journey. But no, she takes joy in others' pain, cheats on her husband, and doesn't even want to be alive. For me, Anse doggedly (ha ha. ha) dragging the rest of the family down with him to bury Addie just looks even more pathetic than it already was when we know she never really cared all that much about the location. (Although I believe Jackson is where Darl's being sent, while Jefferson is the city Addie's buried in. All these J's and -sons. What can you do.) I don't know if it really makes it easier to focus on the journey rather than be concerned about the state of Addie's corpse, given how late in the book live Addie shows up, but eh. I guess the ending would be the most important part.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think the fact that Addie wasn't so deserving of the respect of Anse and the rest of his family makes his reasons for the journey even more questionable. Since she was obviously not the best wife to him, it seems strange that he would go so out of his way to honor something she said so many years ago. This makes it more obvious that the real reason for this journey was getting his new teeth. Without the chapter from Addie's perspective, we might not realize he was so self centered.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I don't think Faulkner was trying to make Addie a character that you weren't supposed to like, I think our views are just really different from hers and so it's harder to sympathize. However, I can see someone feeling bad for her, getting stuck in a marriage to a man she doesn't love, not liking her own children yet having to raise them and take care of them everyday, just in general feeling bad about life and thinking it's only purpose is to stay dead. <- That sounds like a really crappy existence. I however still don't like Addie haha. I just don't appreciate the pessimism. That was how her father thought but that didn't mean she had to grow up thinking that way. It doesn't seem like explaining life was to prep for death was a daily/small talk kind of thing that came up all the time and got drilled into her head.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I felt like Addie's attitude towards life (or death really) was kind of a coping mechanism to make it through. "Everything sucks, but it's ok because one day I'll die and get to rest." Just acknowledging that everything will suck and not hoping for anything kind of makes it easier to bear bad things when they happen. I think Addie's apathy towards almost everything is a way to keep her from getting hurt.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Aside from the issue of sympathizing with Addie, her cynical attitude toward words and concepts like "love" does work to kind of let Anse off the hook a little bit: if we interpret his efforts to bury her as an act of love (and/or "duty"), which so many others see as "a outrage," Addie's own perspective that such words are meaningless and don't even touch the complex underlying reality is relevant. It doesn't matter, in this light, whether Anse is 'really' doing what she wants him to do, or honoring his "sacred vow." She has her reasons to be buried in Jefferson, he has his, and if these reasons aren't compatible, it doesn't really matter.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I also think that this view of Addie sort of lessens the blows of Anse's actions, whether it's disrespecting her coffin or getting a new wife right after (or maybe even a little before) burying Addie. It definitely made me view the whole journey differently because despite Addie being dead, we can see both her and Anse's "faults" and take them as they are.

    ReplyDelete